Durban High Court dismisses appeal in Mkhwanazi defamation case

The Durban High Court has dismissed an application by Calvin Mathibeli to appeal a defamation ruling against him, ordering punitive costs.

In a decision issued on Tuesday, 31 March 2026, the court rejected Mathibeli’s attempt to overturn a February judgment that required him to remove defamatory statements about KwaZulu-Natal police leadership.

What happened

The Durban High Court dismissed Calvin Mathibeli’s application for leave to appeal a previous ruling against him.

The original judgment, delivered on 27 February 2026, ordered Mathibeli to:

• Remove defamatory posts within 24 hours
• Stop making further allegations
• Pay all legal costs

The statements in question were made about Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi on social media, websites, and other digital platforms.

The court found that the allegations were defamatory and damaging.

Why it matters

This ruling reinforces that:

• Defamation on social media has legal consequences
• Courts can order removal of harmful content
• Individuals can be held financially accountable for false claims

According to the police, the allegations had the potential to damage:

• The reputation of Lieutenant General Mkhwanazi
• Public trust in the KwaZulu-Natal police service

Lieutenant General Mkhwanazi welcomed the judgment, saying it sends a clear message about accountability and responsible speech.

What you need to know

• Court: Durban High Court
• Date of appeal dismissal: 31 March 2026
• Original ruling date: 27 February 2026
• Key outcome: Appeal dismissed with punitive costs
• Order remains in place:
  • Remove defamatory content
  • Do not repeat allegations
  • Pay legal costs

What to do next

If you post or share information online:

• Verify claims before publishing
• Avoid making accusations without evidence
• Remove content quickly if found to be false
• Seek legal advice if facing a defamation dispute

This case highlights the risks of spreading unverified claims, especially on public platforms.

Where to get help

If you are dealing with a defamation issue:

• Consult a qualified legal professional
• Refer to official court or legal advisory services
• Use verified government or institutional sources for public claims